People who rightly deserve Social Security Disability Insurance benefits, or SSDI, too often receive denials on their initial claims and at reconsideration. If you’ve received a denial following reconsideration, you can request a hearing before an administrative law judge.
You must present evidence and testimony at the hearing level to convince the judge that you have a qualifying condition that prevents you from working. Proper preparation for a disability hearing and avoiding mistakes, such as inconsistent statements or incomplete evidence, can significantly affect whether a judge grants you benefits. Disability Advice is here to help with pointers to help you prepare for a disability hearing.
What To Expect at a Disability Hearing
If the SSA has denied your initial claim for SSDI benefits and your reconsideration request fails to succeed, it’s likely because the reviewers felt your evidence was insufficient. The purpose of the Social Security disability hearing process is to give you a chance to fill in the blanks so a judge will allow your benefits.
Administrative law judges, or ALJs, may invite witnesses themselves, such as vocational or medical experts, and will question you and all other witnesses. Disability hearings are non-adversarial, so there won’t be anyone present to argue against your claim.
These are the basic steps in a disability hearing:
- The judge explains your claim and issues.
- You or your representative makes a statement summarizing your case.
- You, your witnesses, and witnesses summoned by the judge
- The judge questions you or your representative, as well as the witnesses.
How To Gather the Right Medical Evidence
Receiving SSDI benefits ultimately comes down to presenting evidence of your medical conditions, work history, and current ability to work. You must submit relevant medical documentation, such as test results and diagnoses. Include evidence of the medications you take, their side effects, and any assistive devices you use.
Your medical records must be current. You can ask your doctor to testify so they can explain your condition in detail. If not, ask them for detailed letters explaining your condition and how it prevents you from working.
You must also present a complete work history. Provide evidence about your job tasks and how your condition interferes with your ability to perform such tasks. Obtain personal statements from witnesses not attending your hearing, such as doctors, supervisors, co-workers, friends, and family members, who can attest to your disability and its effects.
Preparing Your Testimony
When you make your case to the judge, address not only your disability but its impacts on your employment prospects. Focus on the daily limitations you face. Note any instances where you tried to work but were unable to. Be ready to discuss whether you can lift or carry things, or walk or sit for long periods.
It is better to overprepare. Keep a journal to remind yourself of things you can no longer do. If you can’t take even a short walk due to severe pain, explain that to the judge so they understand why returning to a job requiring mobility isn’t an option.
Practice your testimony regularly and try to anticipate Social Security disability hearing questions. For example, even if you have previously done only physical labor, you will likely have to explain why you aren’t qualified for or can’t take a sedentary job. Otherwise, the judge will likely deny your claim.
The Role of Your Attorney or Representative
An experienced representative or attorney can assist you by reviewing your claim and determining why your claim failed at previous levels. They can analyze whether your evidence is sufficient for the SSDI approval process. They can work with you to gather the evidence needed and prepare you to testify before the judge. They can also prepare you to answer the judge’s likely questions.
Someone with experience in disability hearings understands the complete picture you must paint and the challenges you may face in a hearing. They also know the laws and terminology involved in SSDI claims, allowing them to make your case to the ALJ more effectively than you can alone.
Your representative or attorney can also assist you in gathering and submitting evidence on time. You must submit your evidence or tell the court about it no later than five business days before your hearing.
Common Mistakes To Avoid
If you have reached the hearing level, you’ve already received denials at the initial claim and reconsideration levels. Any mistakes in front of an ALJ can cost you a third chance at benefits in the SSDI appeals process.
In SSA disability decisions in 2024, reviewers only allowed benefits in 38% of initial claims and 16% of reconsideration requests. ALJs allowed benefits in more than 50% of cases.
Denials of deserving claims at the hearing level generally result from two types of mistakes.
Failing to Prepare Adequately
The ALJ hearing your case needs sufficient information to reach a different conclusion than the SSA reviewers did. Vague testimony due to a lack of preparation will hurt your chances of getting SSDI benefits. Insufficient evidence will lead to the same result.
Generally, you must know inside and out how your disability, its symptoms, and medications affect your ability to concentrate, process information, and perform work tasks. Be ready to discuss when and how your pain or limitations affect you and your ability to work. Have medical evidence or testimony prepared to back up each of your statements.
One of the signs of a good disability hearing is when the judge has few questions because you have already answered them with your testimony and submitted evidence.
Inconsistent Testimony or Evidence
Inconsistent statements or contradictory or unclear evidence can lead a judge to deny your claim for SSDI benefits. Review your testimony and documentation several times before your hearing, and consider the judge’s questions carefully before you answer. If you don’t understand a question, ask for clarification.
Talk to your representative about any evidentiary challenges you may face at the hearing, and if it is possible to address them before the hearing. Ask about their previous experiences with disability judges and the best way to address the reasons for your initial denial.
Preparing for Your Disability Hearing FAQs
These are answers to other questions people commonly have about their disability hearing.
How Long Does a Disability Hearing Take?
A disability hearing generally lasts one to two hours. It may take longer depending on why previous reviewers denied your benefits, the complexity of your disability, and the quality of your evidence. Expert testimony and questioning from the judge, you, or your attorney can also make hearings last longer.
Can I Bring Someone With Me to the Hearing?
Your lawyer or representative can attend the hearing with you, as can your witnesses. The SSA generally does not allow others to be present, unless they are personal aides or family members necessary to assist or support you. If they are not also witnesses, the judge may ask them to return to a waiting area during testimony.
What Should I Wear to the Disability Hearing?
Dressing in business casual shows respect for the judge and the hearing process. Even if subconsciously, a judge may not look favorably on a claimant who shows up in jeans and sneakers. However, try to make yourself as comfortable as possible so your clothes don’t distract you from focusing on your hearing.
Need Help Preparing for Your Disability Hearing?
You need solid medical and other evidence and a well-considered argument to persuade an ALJ at a disability hearing that you deserve SSDI benefits. Disability Advice can connect you with an experienced attorney or advocate who knows how to prepare for a disability hearing and can present your case effectively to an ALJ. Our professionals understand the steps necessary to improve your chances of approval for the benefits you need and deserve.
Contact us today by completing our online form.
- Free case evaluation
- Assist with denied claims
- Ensure you have all documents
- Make the process easy for you
